If you judge what someone’s favourite film is solely on how often they have watched a particular film then this is my all-time favourite film and I watched it again on Christmas Eve. I’ve mentioned in a couple of other posts about how much of a Star Trek fan I was when I was younger and this would have come out when I was nine or ten years old and at the height of my Trek fandom.
A couple of years ago I rewatched and reviewed all ten ‘original’ Star Trek films for a website and here is a repost of my entry for First Contact. It is written to be a little more fanboyish then anything else I’ve posted so far; and it does presuppose some existing knowledge of the Next Generation era of Trek but I’ve tried to amend these parts as much as possible.
Star Trek First Contact (1996)
Dir: Jonathan Frakes
Starring: Patrick Stewart, Jonathan Frakes, Brent Spiner, James Cromwell, Alfre Woodard, Alice Krige, Michael Dorn, LeVar Burton, Gates McFadden, Marina Sirtis, Neal McDonough, Michael Horton
Run-Time: 111 Mins
It was bound to happen sooner or later wasn’t it? Having to review a film that I’m completely incapable of discussing with even a modicum of objectivity.
I can’t hand-on-heart claim that Star Trek: First Contact belongs near a discussion of the best films of all time, but it is my favourite. I’ve watched it more times that I’ve watched any other, and the only thing close to disappointment I feel when I re-watch it again is that it feels too short! I want the space battle scenes to last longer, I want more of Riker, LaForge and Cochran, I want more interactions between Data and the Borg Queen. I suppose that this is evidence that director (and star) Jonathan Frakes has got it just right; First Contact leaves you wanting more while not feeling in the slightest bit short changed.
My raging fanboysim aside, this is the only true contender with Wrath of Khan for the title of best Star Trek film. The Voyage Home and The Undiscovered Country are worthy candidates, the 2009 reboot gets a mention, but these two stand ahead of the rest of the field.
In discussions about what to do with the follow-up to Generations, Producer Rick Berman wanted to do a time-travel story, while writers Brannon Braga and Ronald D. Moore wanted to utilise the Borg (cybernetic zombies in space). They simply combined ideas.
The Borg send a ship back in time to a weaker point in human history and assimilate humanity into their collective.
The Enterprise follows the Borg ship and realises that they are trying to prevent First Contact, an historic event when the humanity meets an alien race for the first time after Zefram Cochrane’s (Cromwell) first ever Warp Drive flight (an early draft had the Borg taking over a renaissance era castle instead.)
While Riker, LaForge and Troi (Frakes, Burton & Sirtis) help ensure that Cochrane’s flight goes ahead, the rest of the Enterprise crew deal with a Borg invasion of the ship, and the kidnapping of Data (Spiner) by the Borg Queen (Krige.)
The script deserves the highest praise, mixing horror, action and some humour, but mostly due to the dialogue. First Contact is the most quoteable Trek film since Khan and one of the most quoteable films in the science-fiction genre. There are any number of bad-ass one liners, memorable replies and well crafted exchanges (an argument between Stewart’s Picard and Dorn’s Worf contains two of the most quoted lines in Trekdom back-to-back) but it also pays attention to character. For a movie criticised for being too action focused and not giving casual audiences enough of a reason to care about any character outside of Picard, Cochrane and Data (and possibly in the grander scheme of things there is something of a point here), the script gives numerous smaller strokes of character; although admittedly these are probably better appreciated by existing fans. Look for example, at the reactions of LaForge and Barclay (The A-Team’s Dwight Schultz) to their hero Cochrane when Geordi is explaining where Cochrane’s statue sits in the 24th Century, or to Worf’s unique solution to his space-suit getting a tear in it.
Better still, in a perfectly neat, lean piece of writing, the eight-year relationship between Riker and Worf is established for the first-time viewer in a mere four words: Worf’s warship, the Defiant is adrift in space and the Enterprise comes to the rescue. Riker, with a grin: “Tough little ship,” Worf’s growled, almost barked response: “Little!?”
And then there’s Patrick Stewart, really getting the chance to sink his teeth into the dialogue, especially in the show-stealing scene, a Moby Dick referencing argument with Cochrane’s assistant, Lily (Woodard) where she questions just how far he is letting personal revenge cloud his decision-making (“Jean-Luc, Blow up the DAMN ship!!!”) Getting into the full-weight and gusto of his Shakespearean background, Stewart’s performance prompted one contemporary reviewer to remark, “here is real acting! In a Star Trek film!”
The ‘guest-cast’ are all good; Alfre Woodard gives a spirited effort, James Cromwell nails the flawed, cynical genius of Cochrane (meeting your heroes is never quite what you expect) while Alice Krige’s simmering, provocative, confident appearance as the Borg Queen is another highlight.
First Contact doesn’t give the whole ensemble cast things to do. This is basically a Picard and Data story, with Riker and Worf supporting along with Geordi to an extent. Crusher gets naff-all to do, Troi barely more.
Director Frakes keeps things moving along at a brisk pace (possibly a little too quick), and he certainly has a handle on action scenes; and not just action scenes of a similar type either as he demonstrates he handles with aplomb space battles, phaser fights, a nightmare-to-shoot upside-down space-walk and a finale where never before has a single torpedo shot meant so much.
The Verdict: This is just kick-ass sci-fi action with tinges of horror and humour. Frantic, relentless fun, strong themes, stronger action and so many quotes…
Actual Rating: 4.5/5
Mike Rating: 10,000,000/5